We grew up with Nutter-Butters. Grandpa always made sure there were some in the cookie jar at his house, and so they are still a favorite cookie because they are associated with so many good memories.
Rarely these days, however, do we ever buy store-bought cookies. It’s our effort to back away from processed foods.
We love this homemade cookie recipe from Kitchen Bellicious. We modified it just a bit to use homemade peanut butter and the result is a divine batch of Nutter-Butters. We hope you enjoy this recipe as much as we do!